Ex. 1
Interestingly, Mars begins with a series of rhythmic pedal on G (Ex. 1). The melody moves in this way: G-D-Db. Subsequent melodic lines make use of this pattern. Looking at the key signature, I'm assuming this movement is centered around some sort of C tonality, but the establishment of this C tonality is quite ambiguous. What lends this beginning special notice is the fact that the pedal G pattern (I'm quite unsure if I should use the term G / dominant pedal or just call it an ostinato pattern) keeps persisting for a large section of the beginning of Mars. Instead of using the dominant as a means of moving away from the tonic and subsequently as a preparation back to the tonic, as is the convention of traditional tonal works, the pedal G pattern at the beginning is used to resolve to the tonic, without even having the tonic established at first.
Ex. 2
Here at Ex. 2, the music is finally going into the tonic (aprox at 2.20min, refer to youtube clip posted by lovelove), as can be seen by the C bass (piano 1), which is further reinforced by that characteristic rhythmic pattern. A climax is built up here. There're two things that happen here which could have a strong pull towards the tonic (C). First, the perrsistant dominat (G) pedal. Second, the leading note B, which occurs in context of a Bmaj triad rather than in a dominant Gmaj chord. There's an interesting play of tension here. On one hand, there is some relief on arriving on the tonic, at the same time new tension is created with the Dbmaj triad over a C bass, which makes it sound "not quite there yet".
I think one observation that I've made is that Holst has strong bass movements at certain parts which hint at some sort of key centre. However, what happens above the bass sometimes confuses people, especially when the melody moves in parallel triads (aprox 2.35min). In this way, Holst doesn't use diatonic harmonies (Ex. 3). There's also a play of mixture harmonies here (Amaj vs Amin between first two bars; Cmin vs Cmaj in last 2 couplets)
Ex. 3
Finally at Ex. 4, the music returns to how it started via a minor dominant 9th chord back to the rhythmic pedal on G (aprox 9.15min), but now with more power and aggression rather than as a means for building up the climax like before.
And to round the movement off, Holst decides to end on C, through the repeated C bass (Ex. 5).
Ex. 5

So if you take a look at the big picture, this is a rough outline of the key structure from beginning til end, in the context of C tonality (not particularly C major / minor). It's quite unusual considering how Holst begins on the dominant and ends on the tonic.
G (Ex. 1) - C (Ex. 2) - X (exploring other keys) - G (Ex. 4) - C (Ex. 5)
7 comments:
hey jeanette! I LOVE LOVE the PLANETS!! holst is one of my all time fav 20th C composer! really glad to find a fellow admirer of his music :)
Haha! My first encounter with The Planets was sometime during my teens. I remember being so awed by it that I immediately went to buy the CD!
Yes, it looks like the G-D-Db may actually have some motivic significance. Do follow this up and, if appropriate, use set labels to facilitate your investigation and presentation.
Re Ex. 3 (and possibly elsewhere), consider the mode of the top melody.
Ex. 4 - reconsider your v9/V
Ex. 5 - the reiterative Ab-Db-G chord over C is very striking and calls for some explanation. Is it relatable to other parts of the movement?
Yes, it looks like the G-D-Db may actually have some motivic significance. Do follow this up and, if appropriate, use set labels to facilitate your investigation and presentation.
Re Ex. 3 (and possibly elsewhere), consider the mode of the top melody.
Ex. 4 - reconsider your v9/V
Ex. 5 - the reiterative Ab-Db-G chord over C is very striking and calls for some explanation. Is it relatable to other parts of the movement?
Re your uncertainty over whether to use the term 'pedal' or 'ostinato' for the opening, think more carefully of what the two terms mean, you should then be able to decide which term(s) to use and how.
The B-C and Db-C tendencies which you noted seems potentially promising as an analytical observation. Note the symmetry around C?
Further thinking on 'ostinato' and 'pedal'
Ostinato: It means obstinate, or stubborn in Italian. An ostinato is a persistently repeated musical figure or rhythm.
Pedal: A harmonic device in which a note is sustained over changing harmonies.
Perhaps it's possible to apply both these terms to the opening of Mars. From a rhythmic perspective, the tri-pe-let ta ta ti-ti ta rhythm can be seen as an ostinato pattern, because of it's persistent repetition. At the same time, from a harmonic perspective, the sustained / repeated G can be seen as a pedal.
I do realise that these 2 terms hold different meanings. It's good to always clarify terms you may take for granted!
Yes, you've gotten it right! These are two different terms but in the case of Holst here, the pedal is articulated in the form of an ostinato.
Post a Comment